Hidden Gems
Hidden gem mystery movies
Whodunits and slow reveals that get everyone guessing out loud. These are the mystery movies that earned strong ratings without the big audience — well-reviewed films that flew under the radar, ranked by weighted rating within a lower vote-count band. Right now that includes Witness for the Prosecution, Rebecca and Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 2. Surface one for the group and call it a discovery.
Launch this as a poll
Hidden gem mystery movies
Rebecca
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 2
Three Colors: Red
Forgotten
Infernal Affairs
Pre-loads the top 6 into a poll — edit the lineup, share the link, and let your group vote.
The full ranking
- #1
Witness for the Prosecution
19578.2
- #2
Rebecca
19407.9
- #3
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 2
20137.9
- #4
Three Colors: Red
19947.9
- #5
Forgotten
20177.9
- #6
Infernal Affairs
20027.8
#7Solaris
19727.8
#8Batman: Under the Red Hood
20107.8
#9Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 1
20127.7
#10Notorious
19467.7
#11The Maltese Falcon
19417.7
#12Mother
20097.7
#13Mississippi Burning
19887.7
#14Deep Red
19757.7
#15Charade
19637.7
#16The Body
20127.5
#17The Book of Henry
20177.5
#18The Man Who Knew Too Much
19567.4
#19Three Colors: White
19947.4
#20Burning
20187.4
More mystery movies to vote on
- Top Rated
The best mystery movies
- Trending
Mystery movies trending right now
- In Theaters
Mystery movies in theaters now
- Upcoming
Upcoming mystery movies
- Highest Grossing
Highest-grossing mystery movies
All mystery movies templates · Browse every genre · Browse by streaming service
FAQ
- What makes a mystery film a "hidden gem" here?
- A high weighted rating combined with a relatively small number of votes — films that are well-loved by the people who've seen them but haven't reached a wide audience yet.
- Are foreign-language films included?
- Yes. Hidden-gem lists span all languages, which is often where the most overlooked mystery movies live.
- Can I make a poll from these?
- Yes — tap "Use This Template" and the picks pre-load into a shareable poll.
Make it your group's pick
Turn any of these into a poll in a tap. A free poll holds up to six options — Pro unlocks unlimited options and polls.