movie night polls logoMovie Night Polls

In Theaters

Mystery movies in theaters now

Whodunits and slow reveals that get everyone guessing out loud. These mystery movies are in theaters right now, updated daily from current US showtimes. Right now that includes A Story of Derry, Heartland and Verity. Poll the group and pick the one worth the trip.

Launch this as a poll

Mystery movies in theaters now

  • A Story of Derry poster

    A Story of Derry

  • Heartland poster

    Heartland

  • Verity poster

    Verity

  • You Can't Leave poster

    You Can't Leave

  • The Cycle poster

    The Cycle

  • The Whistler poster

    The Whistler

Pre-loads the top 6 into a poll — edit the lineup, share the link, and let your group vote.

The full ranking

  1. A Story of Derry#1

    A Story of Derry

    20266.6

  2. Heartland#2

    Heartland

    20266.3

  3. Verity#3

    Verity

    20267.0

  4. You Can't Leave#4

    You Can't Leave

    2026

  5. The Cycle#5

    The Cycle

    20266.8

  6. The Whistler#6

    The Whistler

    20264.9

  7. The Last Kiss#7

    The Last Kiss

    20266.3

  8. Five Figurines#8

    Five Figurines

    2026

  9. DreamQuil#9

    DreamQuil

    20266.5

  10. The Pastor Who Preys#10

    The Pastor Who Preys

    20263.0

  11. Orion#11

    Orion

    2026

  12. Land of Shadows#12

    Land of Shadows

    20269.0

  13. Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage#13

    Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage

    20263.4

  14. Hope Street: One of Our Own#14

    Hope Street: One of Our Own

    2026

  15. Capturing Bigfoot#15

    Capturing Bigfoot

    20267.8

  16. Company#16

    Company

    20265.5

  17. The Manor: First Encounter#17

    The Manor: First Encounter

    2026

  18. A Ghost at Gilmore House#18

    A Ghost at Gilmore House

    20262.0

  19. Letters This Christmas#19

    Letters This Christmas

    2026

  20. To Catch a Stepfather#20

    To Catch a Stepfather

    20269.0

More mystery movies to vote on

All mystery movies templates · Browse every genre · Browse by streaming service

FAQ

Are these mystery movies actually in theaters now?
Yes — the list is built from TMDB's now-playing data for US theaters and refreshes daily, filtered to mystery movies.
Why are there only a few titles?
Theatrical slates are small, and not every genre has new releases every week. When too few mystery movies are playing, this page intentionally stays light rather than padding the list.
Can my group vote without accounts?
Yes. Start a poll from the list and anyone with the link can vote — no signup required.

Make it your group's pick

Turn any of these into a poll in a tap. A free poll holds up to six options — Pro unlocks unlimited options and polls.